Steakhouse Potato Salad

Why This Steakhouse Potato Salad Means So Much to Me

I still remember the first time I tasted steakhouse potato salad. It was one of those warm summer afternoons at my aunt’s place.

The table was full of grilled meats and coolers packed with drinks, but it was the big, chilled bowl of creamy potato salad that I couldn’t stop thinking about. It was cheesy, tangy, filled with crunchy bacon — and it became my new favorite comfort food.

Years later, I’ve recreated that same rich, flavorful salad — with a little twist of my own — to bring that joy to every table.

Craving more delicious ways to enjoy potatoes? Don’t miss our full potato salad recipe collection for creamy, smoky, and herb-packed favorites.

What Is Steakhouse Potato Salad

What Makes It “Steakhouse” Style?

Steakhouse potato salad isn’t your average backyard picnic side. It’s bold, indulgent, and packed with steakhouse-level flavor — think crispy bacon, sharp cheddar, tangy sour cream, and a hint of dill all wrapped around tender red potatoes.

It’s rich enough to stand next to a juicy ribeye but refreshing enough to balance out heavier meat dishes. That contrast — creamy with a crunch, savory with a zing — is what gives it its name and fame.

Unlike the deli-style mayo-only versions, this salad brings layers of texture and taste, making it the kind of side dish that doesn’t just sit quietly on your plate. It speaks up. And it steals the show.

Key Differences Between Traditional and Steakhouse Potato Salads

Feature	Traditional Potato Salad	Steakhouse Potato Salad
Base	Mostly mayonnaise	Mayonnaise + sour cream + mustard
Add-ins	Eggs, celery	Bacon, cheddar, red onion, dill pickles
Potatoes	Russet or Yukon Gold	Red potatoes (skin on)
Flavor profile	Mild and creamy	Bold, tangy, rich, and cheesy
Texture	Soft	Creamy with crunchy textures

So why do people love steakhouse potato salad? Because it’s a full sensory experience — hearty, flavorful, and deeply satisfying. It turns a simple potato salad into a restaurant-worthy side dish that elevates every meal.

And honestly? Once you try this version, there’s no going back.

Print

Ingredients for the Ultimate Steakhouse Potato Salad

If you’re a fan of the traditional American-style potato salad, the Hellmann’s potato salad recipe offers that nostalgic, creamy goodness everyone grew up loving.

Must-Have Ingredients for Authentic Flavor

The beauty of steakhouse potato salad lies in its bold, rich flavor — and that comes from the carefully chosen ingredients. Let’s break it down:

• Red Potatoes (2 pounds): These hold their shape better than russets. Their smooth, waxy texture makes every bite creamy yet firm — the base of a perfect steakhouse potato salad.
• Mayonnaise (½ cup): Provides that rich, creamy foundation.
• Sour Cream (¼ cup): This adds tanginess and softens the intensity of mayo, giving steakhouse potato salad its signature smooth texture.
• Apple Cider Vinegar (2 tbsp): Brightens the flavor and helps balance out the richness.
• Dijon Mustard (2 tbsp): Adds a subtle heat and sharpness to the mix.
• Red Onion (1 small, finely chopped): Offers a sharp, crunchy contrast to the creamy base.
• Cooked Bacon (5 strips, crumbled): Smoky, salty, and essential — this is what brings the steakhouse feel home.
• Shredded Cheddar Cheese (1 cup): Sharp, melty, and indulgent. Choose between mild, medium, or sharp depending on your taste.
• Fresh Parsley (¼ cup, chopped): Brings a pop of freshness.
• Dill Pickles (¼ cup, chopped): Crunchy and sour — it lifts the heaviness of the dish beautifully.
• Salt & Black Pepper: To taste.
• Chopped Chives or Green Onions (optional): Garnish to finish with color and bite.

This isn’t just another salad — every ingredient in this steakhouse potato salad plays its part in creating something memorable.

Customizing Your Potato Salad

Need to make it your own? Here are a few ways to switch it up while staying true to that “steakhouse potato salad” soul:

• Add hard-boiled eggs for extra protein and richness.
• Swap mayo with Greek yogurt for a lighter twist without losing creaminess.
• Use smoked cheddar or pepper jack if you like heat.
• Try sweet pickles instead of dill for a softer flavor profile.
• Add a dash of hot sauce for a little kick that pairs perfectly with grilled meats.

Here’s a quick overview:

Ingredient	Possible Substitution
Sour Cream	Plain Greek yogurt
Red Onion	Green onion or shallot
Bacon	Turkey bacon or veggie bacon
Cheddar	Smoked gouda or pepper jack
Pickles	Sweet relish or chopped jalapeños

This version of steakhouse potato salad isn’t just flexible — it’s irresistible.

FOLLOW ME IN PINTEREST FOR MORE RECIPES

Step-by-Step Instructions

Boiling and Prepping the Potatoes

To make a flawless steakhouse potato salad, your potatoes need to be tender but never mushy. Here’s how to get it right:

1. Wash and cube 2 pounds of red potatoes. Cut them into bite-sized pieces, about 1-inch cubes. You can peel them, but leaving the skin on adds color and texture — just like in most steakhouse potato salad recipes.
2. Place potatoes in a large pot and cover them with cold water. This helps them cook evenly.
3. Bring to a boil over medium-high heat. Once it starts boiling, reduce to medium and let it simmer for about 10–15 minutes, or until fork-tender (don’t overcook — you want structure).
4. Drain and cool. Pour the cooked potatoes into a colander and let them cool down to room temperature. Don’t skip this step — if they’re too warm when mixed, they’ll absorb too much dressing and turn mushy.

Now that your potatoes are prepped, let’s move to the fun part — building the creamy, savory base of your steakhouse potato salad.

Mixing the Dressing and Assembling the Salad

Here’s how to create that unforgettable creamy bite:

1. Make the dressing: In a large bowl, combine:
   • ½ cup mayonnaise
   • ¼ cup sour cream
   • 2 tablespoons Dijon mustard
   • 2 tablespoons apple cider vinegar
   Whisk it all together until smooth and well blended.
2. Add the goodies: Into the same bowl, toss in:
   • The cooled red potatoes
   • 1 small finely chopped red onion
   • 5 crispy cooked bacon strips, crumbled
   • 1 cup shredded cheddar cheese
   • ¼ cup chopped dill pickles
   • ¼ cup chopped fresh parsley
3. Mix gently: Using a spatula or large spoon, fold everything together gently — you want every chunk coated without smashing the potatoes.
4. Season to taste: Add salt and black pepper. Stir gently once more.
5. Chill to enhance flavor: Cover the bowl with plastic wrap or a lid and refrigerate for at least 1 hour to let the flavors blend. Don’t overdo it — too long in the fridge and the potatoes will soak up too much dressing. If needed, stir in a little extra mayo before serving to bring back that creamy texture.
6. Garnish just before serving: Sprinkle with chopped chives or sliced green onions to finish it off with a fresh pop.

And there you have it — a steakhouse potato salad that rivals any dish you’d get at a high-end grill. It’s creamy, tangy, crunchy, and packed with flavor.

Tips to Perfect the Texture and Flavor

How to Keep Your Potato Salad Creamy, Not Mushy

The magic of steakhouse potato salad lies in its contrast — tender potatoes wrapped in creamy dressing with just enough crunch to keep it exciting. But getting that texture right isn’t always easy. Here’s how to nail it every time:

• Start with cold water: Always place your diced potatoes in cold water before boiling. Dropping them into hot water makes the outside cook too fast and break down before the inside is done.
• Don’t overcook: Test them early. You want a fork to pierce through without the potato falling apart. Slight firmness is okay — it continues to soften slightly as it cools.
• Cool completely before mixing: This is a critical step in making sure your steakhouse potato salad stays creamy, not gluey. Warm potatoes absorb more dressing and can make the salad dense.
• Use a rubber spatula: When combining everything, gently fold instead of stirring aggressively. Keep those potato chunks intact for a hearty, steakhouse-style finish.

For a fresher, mayo-free alternative, explore our Ina Garten French potato salad made with herbs, Dijon, and olive oil — a classy twist on a classic.

Balancing Tang, Salt, and Richness

Too tangy? Too bland? Not creamy enough? Don’t worry — here’s how to balance it all:

Flavor Element	How to Boost It
Tang	Add more apple cider vinegar or Dijon mustard
Richness	Add an extra scoop of mayonnaise or a dash of heavy cream
Saltiness	Increase crumbled bacon or a sprinkle of sea salt
Freshness	Add more dill pickles, parsley, or a squeeze of lemon
Heat (Optional)	Dash of hot sauce or cayenne pepper

These micro-adjustments ensure every bite of your steakhouse potato salad hits all the right notes. Creamy. Savory. Tangy. Crunchy. Exactly how it should be.

And here’s a little secret: letting the salad sit for 1–2 hours before serving helps the flavors marry beautifully. Just give it a gentle stir and adjust the texture with an extra spoonful of dressing, if needed.

Steakhouse Potato Salad Variations

Spicy Twist with Jalapeños or Hot Sauce

Want to bring a little heat to your classic steakhouse potato salad? It’s easier than you think. The creamy base makes a perfect canvas for spice — it balances out bold flavors without overwhelming your palate.

Here are a few spicy upgrades to try:

• Chopped fresh jalapeños: Add them raw for serious crunch and spice, or roast them first for a smoky kick.
• Hot sauce drizzle: A tablespoon or two of your favorite hot sauce stirred into the dressing takes the flavor up a notch.
• Chipotle powder or cayenne: Add ½ tsp to the dressing to deepen the flavor without making it overpowering.
• Spicy pickles: Swap in jalapeño pickles for an extra zing.

These spicy variations give your steakhouse potato salad an unexpected, fiery personality — perfect for BBQ lovers and spice fans alike.

Lighter Greek Yogurt Option

If you’re watching calories or just want a tangier base, Greek yogurt makes an excellent substitute in your steakhouse potato salad. It doesn’t sacrifice flavor, and the texture remains beautifully creamy.

Try this lighter version:

• Replace ½ cup mayo with ½ cup plain Greek yogurt.
• Keep the ¼ cup sour cream or swap it for yogurt too, depending on how light you want it.
• Add a bit more mustard or vinegar to punch up the flavor, since yogurt is milder than mayo.

Why it works: Greek yogurt adds protein, lowers fat content, and still delivers that luscious, thick texture that makes every forkful satisfying.

Ingredient	Light Swap Option
Mayonnaise	Plain Greek yogurt
Bacon	Turkey bacon
Cheddar	Reduced-fat cheese
Sour cream	Low-fat or light sour cream

With just a few easy tweaks, your steakhouse potato salad stays indulgent — but better suited for lighter meals or health-conscious guests.

Make-Ahead & Storage Advice

Can You Refrigerate It Overnight?

Yes, you can make steakhouse potato salad ahead of time — but with one important warning: don’t let it sit for too long before serving. The longer it chills, the more the potatoes absorb the creamy dressing, and your perfect salad can turn dry.

Here’s how to keep your salad just as rich and creamy the next day:

• Refrigerate for 1–4 hours before serving for best texture and flavor infusion.
• Add extra dressing right before serving if it’s been sitting for more than 4 hours. A few tablespoons of mayo or sour cream will bring it back to life.
• Garnish last: Add chives or green onions after chilling, just before serving — they stay fresher and more vibrant.

If you’re prepping steakhouse potato salad for a potluck, BBQ, or next-day dinner, store it right and stir it gently before serving. It’ll taste just like you made it fresh.

Best Containers and Reheating Tips

Storage containers matter more than you think. To keep your salad from drying out or soaking up fridge odors:

• Use an airtight glass or BPA-free plastic container with a sealed lid.
• Avoid aluminum — it can react with vinegar-based dressings.
• Store the salad in the back of the fridge, where the temperature is most consistent.

Reheating tip: Honestly? Don’t reheat your steakhouse potato salad. It’s designed to be eaten cold or room temperature. If it’s too cold from the fridge, let it sit out for 15–20 minutes before serving for best flavor.

Need to prep earlier than a few hours ahead? Here’s a trick:

1. Boil and prep the potatoes a day early.
2. Mix the dressing and extras separately.
3. Combine just a few hours before serving.

This way, your steakhouse potato salad stays fresh, creamy, and full of that bold flavor everyone expects.

Love smoky flavors? Try our smoked potato salad with deep BBQ notes and a grilled finish that screams cookout season.

Pairing Ideas — What to Serve With Steakhouse Potato Salad

Perfect Main Dishes (Steaks, BBQ, Ribs)

What makes steakhouse potato salad so special is how versatile and indulgent it is. It can stand proudly next to a ribeye, smoky BBQ chicken, or even a slow-cooked brisket.

Here are the most mouthwatering pairings:

• Grilled Steak: Whether it’s a NY strip, ribeye, or filet mignon, the creamy and tangy flavors of steakhouse potato salad cut right through the richness of the meat.
• BBQ Ribs or Pulled Pork: That cheesy-bacon combo balances out the smoky sweetness of barbecue sauce.
• Smoked Sausages or Brats: The contrast of sharp cheddar and dill pickles plays beautifully with juicy, savory sausages.
• Rotisserie Chicken: For a lighter meal, pair this salad with simple roasted or grilled chicken — it still feels hearty and filling.
• Seared Tuna or Salmon: The creamy base cools down spicy or peppery seafood, making for a unique surf-and-turf-inspired meal.

These protein pairings elevate your steakhouse potato salad from a side dish to an essential part of your meal.

Unexpected But Delicious Pairings

Want to break the mold? Try some non-traditional pairings that still let your steakhouse potato salad shine:

• Veggie Burgers or Portobello Mushrooms: The smokiness of grilled mushrooms pairs beautifully with the creamy, bacon-filled salad.
• Corn on the Cob: The sweetness of fresh corn offsets the tang of mustard and pickles.
• Baked Beans: A classic picnic favorite — slightly sweet, slightly smoky, and an ideal contrast in both flavor and texture.
• Crusty Garlic Bread: Scoop a little salad onto the bread for a satisfying crunch and cream combo.
• Deviled Eggs or Egg Salad: If you’re going all-in on comfort food, these soft, creamy bites belong on the same plate.

Pairings like these make every bite of your steakhouse potato salad more enjoyable. Whether you’re planning a backyard cookout, Sunday dinner, or a relaxed picnic, this dish adapts effortlessly.

Steakhouse Potato Salad & Health

Nutritional Breakdown of the Recipe

Let’s be honest — steakhouse potato salad isn’t meant to be a “light” dish. It’s indulgent, rich, and comforting. But when made from scratch, it still beats store-bought versions in both flavor and ingredient quality.

Here’s an approximate nutritional snapshot per 1-cup serving:

Nutrient	Amount
Calories	280–320 kcal
Protein	6–9 grams
Total Fat	20–23 grams
Carbohydrates	18–20 grams
Fiber	2 grams
Sodium	350–480 mg
Sugar	2–4 grams

The calorie count can vary based on the amount of cheese, bacon, and mayonnaise used — or if you swap in lighter alternatives like Greek yogurt.

One thing is clear: this steakhouse potato salad provides a hearty, protein-rich side option that keeps you full and satisfied — especially when paired with lean meats or grilled veggies.

How to Make It Healthier Without Losing Flavor

If you’re looking to lighten the dish while keeping the creamy, savory flavor that defines a true steakhouse potato salad, try these smart adjustments:

• Use Greek yogurt instead of sour cream to increase protein and reduce fat.
• Reduce the bacon or use turkey bacon.
• Go light on the cheese or use a low-fat variety.
• Skip the mayo entirely and try an avocado-based dressing.
• Add extra herbs like dill, parsley, or even basil for freshness without added calories.
• Control the salt — with bacon, cheese, and pickles, it can add up fast.

Want to dive deeper into how these swaps impact your health?

• Read more about healthy fat choices from Mayo Clinic
• https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/resistant-starch-101Explore the benefits of potatoes and resistant starch on Healthline

Remember, it’s all about balance. A scoop of steakhouse potato salad made with fresh ingredients, shared with good company, is a win for the soul — and your taste buds.

Frequently Asked Questions

FOLLOW ME IN PINTEREST FOR MORE RECIPES