Black Walnut Ice Cream – A Deeply Nostalgic Homemade Treat You’ll Crave Forever

Black walnut ice cream isn’t just another flavor—it’s a memory frozen in time. I still remember the first time I tried it. I was visiting my grandfather’s old farmhouse in Kentucky. After dinner, he handed me a bowl of what looked like plain vanilla—but one bite, and I was hooked.

Recipe Guide

Toggle

The deep, bold, nutty flavor? Nothing like the store-bought stuff I grew up with. Since that day, I’ve been chasing that taste, and after dozens of tries, I finally nailed a black walnut ice cream recipe that takes me right back there. If you’ve never tried this, you’re in for something unforgettable.

And if you have, you know—this isn’t just dessert. It’s tradition, nostalgia, and comfort… churned into creamy perfection. Ready to bring that taste back to life?

Want more cool recipes like this one? Browse our full Ice Cream category for even more creamy ideas.

The Creamy Legend of Black Walnut Ice Cream

How I Fell in Love with Black Walnut Ice Cream

There’s a reason black walnut ice cream still stirs hearts—even if you rarely find it on supermarket shelves. For me, it was the gateway to a deeper kind of flavor. As a kid, I only knew ice cream to be sweet, soft, and familiar—vanilla, chocolate, maybe strawberry on weekends.

But the moment I tasted the rugged, earthy bite of black walnuts folded into silky cream, everything changed. It wasn’t just sweet. It was soulful.

That bowl of black walnut ice cream became more than dessert. It was the story of my family, especially my grandfather, who used to harvest black walnuts by hand each fall. He’d let them dry for weeks before cracking them open with a hammer in the shed.

Making ice cream from those was his way of preserving not just the nuts—but our history.

And now, every time I make it, it feels like I’m bringing him back into the kitchen with me.

Why This Forgotten Classic Deserves a Comeback

Why did this masterpiece of a flavor almost vanish? It’s not because people stopped loving it—it’s because they forgot about it. Today, flavors that scream with sugar and dye grab all the spotlight. But black walnut ice cream? It’s patient. It’s deep. It waits for those with a mature palate to appreciate its earthy bitterness balanced by creamy sweetness.

What makes this ice cream so unique is that it doesn’t try to be everything to everyone. It’s bold, distinct, and unapologetically rich. It’s not just an indulgence—it’s a rediscovery. And it’s time we brought it back. Making your own means no preservatives, no artificial flavors—just real black walnuts, real cream, and a whole lot of heart.

So if you’re someone who believes that food should have soul, depth, and a story to tell, this one’s for you. Because black walnut ice cream isn’t just old-fashioned—it’s timeless.

If you’re looking for something light and naturally rich, our Goat Milk Ice Cream offers a refreshing twist on traditional dairy.

Understanding the Unique Flavor Profile of Black Walnut Ice Cream

What Makes Black Walnuts Taste Different from Regular Walnuts

If you’ve ever tried both, you know that black walnuts are in a league of their own. Unlike English walnuts, which are mild, buttery, and a bit sweet, black walnuts are bold—almost wild. Their taste is darker, earthier, slightly bitter, and deeply nutty. That’s exactly why black walnut ice cream carries such a strong personality.

The difference comes from their growing process. Black walnut trees pull nutrients from deep in the soil, and the nuts develop a dense, pungent flavor over time. It’s this exact profile that gives the ice cream its unmistakable edge.

They’re not mass-farmed like the common walnut. That rarity? It adds exclusivity to every bite. Every spoonful of black walnut ice cream becomes a full sensory experience—an explosion of robust flavor wrapped in velvety cream.

Using black walnuts isn’t just a choice. It’s a statement.

How Black Walnuts Create a Bold and Bitter-Sweet Ice Cream Flavor

The magic happens when that slightly bitter edge of the black walnut hits the rich sweetness of cream and sugar. That’s what sets black walnut ice cream apart. It’s a dance of contrasts: creamy yet textured, sweet but complex, soft with a crunch.

The natural oils in black walnuts intensify during the heating process. When simmered into cream, they create a nutty base that feels almost toasted. Add a real vanilla bean and slowly cooked egg yolks, and the flavor goes from good to gourmet.

This isn’t your basic nutty ice cream. It’s layered. It’s grown-up. It has attitude.

And here’s something I learned: chilling the walnut-infused cream overnight enhances the flavor even more. Letting the oils steep and settle brings out a subtle bitterness that balances perfectly with the custard base. It’s like aging a fine wine—but in your freezer.

For anyone chasing flavor depth, black walnut ice cream is not just dessert—it’s the destination.

Black Walnut Ice Cream

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

No reviews

Print Recipe

Bring back bold, nostalgic flavor with this homemade Black Walnut Ice Cream—a rich, custard-style treat featuring earthy black walnuts, real vanilla bean, and creamy texture you won’t forget. Perfect for holidays, family gatherings, or a cozy dessert night. Make it today and relive the tradition in every scoop!

Try this bold, old-fashioned recipe now – it’s easier than you think!

• Total Time: 5 hours
• Yield: 8

Ingredients

Scale 1x2x3x

• 2 cups heavy cream
• 2 cups whole milk
• 2/3 cup black walnuts (roughly chopped)
• 2/3 cup granulated sugar
• 1/2 vanilla bean (split and scraped)
• 4 –5 large egg yolks

Cook Mode Prevent your screen from going dark

Instructions

Infuse the Flavor

1. In a heavy saucepan, combine cream, milk, sugar, and chopped black walnuts.
2. Heat to 170°F until steaming (do not simmer).
3. Turn off heat, add vanilla bean and scraped seeds.
4. Cover and let steep for 1 hour.

🔹 Chill the Base

1. Transfer to a container and chill for 4 hours or overnight.
2. Strain mixture, reserving walnuts. Set them aside.

🔹 Make the Custard

1. Reheat strained cream to 160°F.
2. Whisk egg yolks in a bowl.
3. Temper yolks by adding 2 ladles of hot cream, whisking constantly.
4. Pour yolk mixture into the pot. Stir over medium-low heat for 5 minutes, until thickened. Do not boil.

🔹 Strain & Cool

1. Strain again, let cool to room temperature. Chill fully in the fridge.

🔹 Churn & Freeze

1. Pour chilled custard into ice cream maker. Churn until soft-serve texture.
2. Gently fold in reserved walnuts.
3. Transfer to container. Freeze for at least 4 hours before serving.

📌 Pro Tips:

1. Press plastic wrap directly on the surface before freezing to prevent ice crystals.
2. Add caramel swirls or chocolate chunks for fun variations.
3. For an adult twist, add 1 tbsp bourbon to the custard before churning.

Notes

Nutrition Information (Per Serving)

Nutrient	Amount
Calories	330 kcal
Total Fat	24 g
Saturated Fat	13 g
Cholesterol	170 mg
Sodium	35 mg
Carbohydrates	22 g
Sugars	18 g
Protein	5 g
Fiber	1 g
Calcium	130 mg

 

• Prep Time: 30 minutes
• Cook Time: 30 minutes
• Category: Dessert
• Cuisine: American

Black Walnut Ice Cream Ingredients Breakdown

Ingredient List with Measurements

To make authentic black walnut ice cream, you don’t need anything fancy—but every ingredient must be fresh and real. Here’s what you’ll need to whip up the batch that’s as creamy and nostalgic as it gets:

Each item in this list is here for a reason—and not one can be skipped if you want to capture the true essence of black walnut ice cream.

Craving layers of chocolate, peanuts, and marshmallow? Don’t miss our fun and flavorful Tin Roof Sundae Ice Cream.

Why Each Ingredient Matters in the Final Flavor and Texture

Heavy Cream and Milk
These are the heart of the ice cream. The balance of cream and milk gives you the perfect mix of richness without being overly fatty. The cream gives that dense mouthfeel, while milk keeps it light enough to let the black walnut flavor shine.

Black Walnuts
This is your star. Their flavor doesn’t hide—it roars. Roughly chopped, they infuse the base with their earthy oils and provide crunch when folded in at the end. Unlike regular walnuts, black walnuts create a unique bitter-sweet contrast with the custard base.

Sugar
More than sweetness, sugar keeps your ice cream scoopable and smooth. It lowers the freezing point so that your black walnut ice cream stays soft and luscious instead of icy and stiff.

Vanilla Bean
Skip the extract. Real vanilla bean adds complexity that enhances the nutty profile. The tiny black specks from the bean also give your ice cream a visual cue that it’s the real deal.

Egg Yolks
These give the custard its luxurious texture. They act as emulsifiers, making sure every bite is silky and creamy. Tempering them correctly (we’ll cover this in the next part) is the secret to success.

Optional Enhancer: A Pinch of Salt
Just a pinch will make the nut flavor pop even more. Salt balances bitterness and brings a smooth finish.

And remember—every time you gather these ingredients and stir them together, you’re not just making dessert. You’re bringing black walnut ice cream back to life, one scoop at a time.

Step-by-Step Instructions for Homemade Black Walnut Ice Cream

Tempering the Egg Yolks Without Scrambling Them

Here’s where many people mess up—but you won’t. Making custard-based black walnut ice cream is all about control. The egg yolks give the ice cream its velvety, scoopable texture, but they’re sensitive. If you rush the process, you’ll end up with scrambled eggs instead of silky ice cream.

Follow these steps like gospel:

1. Heat Your Cream Base:
   In a heavy-bottomed saucepan, combine 2 cups cream, 2 cups whole milk, 2/3 cup sugar, and 2/3 cup roughly chopped black walnuts. Warm the mixture slowly until it reaches 170°F—it should steam but never bubble.
   Turn off the heat and stir in the scraped vanilla bean and pod. Cover and let steep for 1 hour to let the walnut oils infuse.
2. Cool and Chill:
   Transfer to a container and refrigerate for at least 4 hours—overnight is even better. This resting stage boosts the intensity of the black walnut flavor.
3. Strain and Separate:
   Once chilled, strain the base to remove the nuts and vanilla pod. Save the walnut bits—you’ll fold them in later.

Now, the big moment—tempering:

4. Reheat to 160°F:
   Bring your strained base back to 160°F. While it’s heating, whisk 4–5 egg yolks in a separate bowl until smooth.
5. Temper the Yolks:
   Slowly add a ladle of the hot cream into the yolks while whisking constantly. Repeat this with a second ladle. This process slowly warms the yolks so they don’t curdle.
6. Reunite & Cook:
   Pour the tempered yolks back into the pot of hot cream. Stir constantly over medium-low heat for about 5 minutes. Do not let it boil. The custard should thicken slightly—enough to coat the back of a spoon.
7. Final Strain & Chill:
   Strain again to remove any curdles, then chill to room temperature. Cover and refrigerate until cold.

Infusing Flavors for Depth & Creaminess

This part is crucial. Infusing gives black walnut ice cream its signature boldness. When the mixture chills, the oils from the nuts, the fat from the cream, and the aromatics from the vanilla blend in perfect harmony.

8. Churn Time:
   Pour the chilled custard into your ice cream maker and churn until soft-serve consistency. It should take 20–30 minutes, depending on your machine.
9. Add the Crunch:
   Fold in the reserved black walnuts. This adds texture and doubles down on that unforgettable nutty finish.
10. Freeze:
    Transfer to a loaf pan or airtight container. Cover with plastic wrap and freeze for at least 4 hours, or until firm.

Once set, you’ve got homemade black walnut ice cream that’s pure nostalgia with every bite.

Pro Tips for Perfect Black Walnut Ice Cream Texture

Avoiding Over-Churning and Ice Crystals

You’ve followed the steps, nailed the custard, and churned it to perfection—so don’t let texture ruin the magic now. Getting that silky, scoopable consistency is all about knowing when to stop and how to store. Black walnut ice cream deserves nothing less than creamy excellence.

First rule: Don’t over-churn. Once your mixture reaches soft-serve consistency in the machine—thick but still pliable—it’s done. Over-churning forces too much air into the mix, creating a grainy texture. Aim for 20–30 minutes, depending on your model.

Ice crystals are the enemy. To avoid them:

• Always chill the custard completely before churning. If your base is even slightly warm, you’ll end up with a gritty mess.
• Use a container with minimal air exposure. I love using loaf pans covered tightly with plastic wrap, pressed directly on the surface.
• After transferring your churned black walnut ice cream to the container, don’t stir or agitate it too much. Keep it smooth.
• Store it at the back of your freezer, where the temperature stays consistent.

Consistency matters as much as flavor, and with these tips, your ice cream will stay creamy, dreamy, and frustration-free.

Chilling and Curing: Why Patience Makes It Perfect

Here’s something nobody tells you: freshly churned ice cream isn’t the best version of itself. Black walnut ice cream needs time to mature in the freezer. That’s where the flavors mellow, bond, and intensify.

Let it rest in the freezer for at least 4 hours after churning. Better yet? Overnight. That extra time allows the custard to solidify evenly, prevents ice crystals, and gives the black walnut flavor a deeper presence.

This process is known as “curing” in the world of ice cream. It’s like aging cheese or wine—flavor deepens and balance improves.

And when you finally scoop it? That first bite will be worth every minute of waiting.

For a bold, nutty ice cream inspired by the Southwest, try our Pinon Ice Cream — it’s earthy, creamy, and totally unique.

The Story Behind the Discontinuation of Black Walnut Ice Cream

Why Big Brands Stopped Producing It

Once upon a time, black walnut ice cream held a proud spot in grocery freezer aisles. You’d find it alongside classics like butter pecan or rocky road. But slowly, quietly, it vanished. Why?

The truth is part economics, part taste trends.

Black walnuts are harder to source than common English walnuts. They grow wild, mostly in the Midwest, and require time-consuming shelling by hand or specialized machinery. That means higher costs. And in an industry built on margins, big brands leaned toward cheaper, crowd-pleasing flavors.

Then there’s the flavor itself. Black walnuts have a bold, sometimes divisive taste. Not everyone’s a fan of the earthy, slightly bitter profile—especially kids. As companies chased “universal appeal,” flavors with deeper character like black walnut ice cream got the boot.

So it wasn’t that it wasn’t loved—it just wasn’t mass loved.

But here’s the twist…

How Small-Batch Makers Are Bringing It Back

While big-box brands backed off, artisan ice cream makers leaned in. Small-batch creameries started reviving black walnut ice cream because people missed it. It became a symbol of nostalgia. A flavor with heritage.

And now, thanks to homemade recipes like this one, you can bring it back too.

When you make black walnut ice cream at home, you’re not just reviving a forgotten flavor—you’re rejecting generic, safe, boring dessert. You’re saying yes to complexity. Yes to memory. Yes to authenticity.

From family cookouts to holiday dinners, serving this ice cream always sparks a story. Someone’s grandma used to make it. Someone else remembers it from a roadside creamery on a road trip. It’s more than dessert—it’s conversation, comfort, and culture.

Flavor Variations You Can Try

Adding Caramel Swirls or Chocolate Chips

Now that you’ve mastered the original, let’s get creative. Black walnut ice cream already packs flavor, but adding a touch of sweetness or texture can make it irresistible for everyone at the table—even those who aren’t sure about black walnuts.

Caramel Swirls:
Drizzle thick ribbons of salted caramel into your ice cream during the final fold (right after churning). The sweet, buttery caramel balances the bold, earthy bitterness of black walnuts, turning every bite into a contrast of bold and smooth. Think of it as the grown-up cousin to butter pecan.

Chocolate Chips or Shavings:
Semi-sweet or dark chocolate pairs beautifully with the rich walnut profile. Use coarsely chopped chocolate chunks, or better yet, shave chocolate directly into the churned ice cream. It creates pockets of melt-in-your-mouth cocoa surprise.

This version of black walnut ice cream is what I serve at holiday dinners—it turns skeptics into lifelong fans.

Pro Tip: Chill your mix-ins before folding them in. Warm caramel or chocolate will melt your base and ruin the texture.

Black Walnut Bourbon Ice Cream for Grown-Ups

Want to impress guests at your next dinner party? Add a shot of bourbon (1–2 tablespoons) to your ice cream base before churning. It gives your black walnut ice cream a warm, smoky edge that pairs incredibly well with the nutty bitterness.

The alcohol also acts as a softener—keeping your ice cream extra scoopable.

Optional Add-ins for Bourbon Variation:

• Toasted coconut flakes
• Candied orange zest
• Crushed toffee bits

You’ll be amazed at how black walnuts carry those deep flavors like a champ. The bourbon version feels luxurious, classy, and a little rebellious—perfect for evenings with friends, or date nights where dessert does the talking.

Serving and Pairing Suggestions

Perfect Pairings: From Warm Pies to Fresh Berries

You’ve churned and frozen the dreamiest batch of black walnut ice cream—now it’s time to serve it in a way that truly celebrates its rich, bold flavor.

Let’s talk pairings. Because this nutty, creamy dessert doesn’t just stand alone—it elevates anything beside it.

Warm Pie Pairings:
There’s something magical about cold, creamy black walnut ice cream melting over a slice of hot pie. These combinations will make your guests swoon:

Fresh Berries:
Tart fruits like raspberries or blackberries add brightness to each spoonful. Just scatter them over a scoop for a gourmet look and taste. Even a handful of pomegranate seeds can bring contrast and crunch.

Simple Syrups or Drizzles:

• Maple syrup: Pairs beautifully with black walnuts
• Honey: Adds smooth floral sweetness
• Espresso drizzle: For coffee lovers who want extra depth

Glass of Red Wine? You bet. A mild Merlot or a spicy Zinfandel can be the ultimate grown-up pairing.

How to Scoop It Like a Pro and Present Like a Chef

Presentation doesn’t have to be complicated, but it should feel intentional. Here’s how to serve black walnut ice cream so it looks as amazing as it tastes:

Scoop Smart:

• Dip your scoop in hot water for clean, round servings.
• Serve it in a chilled bowl to slow down melting.

Add a Crunch:
Top it with reserved black walnut pieces for texture. A dusting of cinnamon or cocoa powder can make it pop on the plate.

Use Layers:
For parties or date nights, layer it into glasses with whipped cream, crushed cookies, or granola for a black walnut parfait.

Garnish with Color:
Mint leaves, edible flowers, or even a thin orange twist can add brightness against the rich cream tones.

Looking for something easy to enjoy on the go? The Coolish Ice Cream Recipe is smooth, mess-free, and fun.

Storage Tips and Shelf Life

Best Containers to Use and Freezing Techniques

Now that you’ve made the perfect batch of black walnut ice cream, you’ll want to keep it fresh, scoopable, and free from freezer burn. The secret? It’s all in the storage.

Here’s what works best:

Use Airtight, Shallow Containers
Shallow containers freeze faster and more evenly, which means fewer ice crystals and a smoother texture. A loaf pan works great if you tightly cover it with plastic wrap pressed directly onto the surface. Or go for BPA-free, airtight ice cream tubs with snug-fitting lids.

Press and Seal
Always press plastic wrap directly onto the surface of the ice cream before sealing the lid. This prevents air contact and wards off ice buildup.

Label and Date
Homemade black walnut ice cream doesn’t have preservatives, so be sure to label your container with the date made. It’s easy to forget—until you dig in three weeks later wondering how old it is.

Avoid Frequent Thawing
Every time you thaw and refreeze, you compromise texture. If you’re serving guests, scoop what you need and return the container to the back of the freezer quickly.

Signs Your Ice Cream Has Gone Bad

Yes, even homemade goodness has a shelf life.

How long does black walnut ice cream last?
Stored properly, it stays at peak flavor and texture for about 2–3 weeks. After that, the flavor may dull, and ice crystals can form—even with good technique.

What to watch for:

• Icy Layer on Top: If there’s a thick layer of frost, it’s been open too long.
• Grainy Texture: Usually from repeated thawing and refreezing.
• Off Smell: Black walnuts have a strong scent, but if it turns sour or stale, toss it.

Pro Tip: Store it at the very back of your freezer where the temperature stays constant.

Treat your black walnut ice cream with the same care you put into making it, and you’ll be rewarded with every creamy, nostalgic bite.

FAQs About Black Walnut Ice Cream

Why Black Walnut Ice Cream Is More Than Just a Dessert!

Black walnut ice cream isn’t just an old-fashioned flavor—it’s a taste of history, of heritage, of stories passed from generation to generation. From the intense aroma of simmering cream and walnuts to the first bite of that deep, nutty creaminess, it’s an experience that sticks with you.

Whether you’re honoring a memory or discovering this nostalgic flavor for the first time, making it at home gives you something no store ever could: tradition, soul, and satisfaction in every scoop.

It’s not just ice cream—it’s a journey back to roots that deserve to be remembered and shared.

FOR MORE RECIPES FOLLOW ME ON PINTEREST