Hawaiian Potato Mac Salad
How Hawaiian Potato Mac Salad Took Me Back to Grandma’s Porch
I first discovered Hawaiian potato mac salad on a trip to Maui, but I didn’t fall in love with it until I tried to make it myself. The moment I stirred warm potatoes into tender elbow macaroni, then added the creamy, tangy dressing, I felt like I was back in my grandma’s kitchen.
She used to make something similar every Sunday—simple, comforting, and packed with love. That memory of her whispering, “Let the flavors sit overnight,” stayed with me. And when I took my first bite of this version, it was like hearing her voice again. This isn’t just food—it’s connection. And once you taste this version, you’ll know why it’s a staple at every Hawaiian plate lunch.
Check out our Category for Potato Salads to explore other side dishes that balance flavor and nutrition.
What Is Hawaiian Potato Mac Salad?
A Classic Dish with Island Soul
Hawaiian potato mac salad is more than just a side dish—it’s a tradition. Served alongside BBQ chicken, kalua pork, or loco moco, this salad brings a rich, creamy contrast to the smoky, savory flavors of a Hawaiian meal. What makes it so special? The combination of soft potatoes and overcooked elbow macaroni soaked in a tangy-sweet mayo-based dressing. It’s chilled for hours, letting the starches absorb every drop of flavor. That’s the magic of a true Hawaiian mac salad—it’s humble, hearty, and unforgettable.
FOLLOW ME IN PINTEREST FOR MORE RECIPES
This dish has become a go-to comfort food not just in the islands but across the mainland too. It’s not overly complex, but each step matters. That’s what separates a forgettable salad from one you’ll dream about after the first bite.
Why It’s Loved Across Hawaii and the Mainland
One reason Hawaiian potato mac salad stands out is its simplicity. There are no bold spices or overpowering extras—just quality ingredients and time-tested technique. Locals believe in overcooking the pasta slightly so it turns soft and creamy rather than al dente. They also insist on using Best Foods or Hellmann’s mayonnaise, because the richness and flavor truly shine through.
Also, the sweet onion and carrot add gentle crunch and sweetness, balancing the dressing. It’s hearty enough to be filling, but not so heavy it takes over the plate. It’s the kind of recipe that quietly steals the spotlight during any cookout or potluck.
Hawaiian Potato Mac Salad
Ingredients
Salad:
- 3 lbs gold potatoes or red/russet, peeled and diced
- 8 oz elbow macaroni
- 2 tsp salt for boiling water
- 1 cup shredded carrots chopped
- 1 medium sweet onion finely shredded
Dressing:
- 1 ½ cups mayonnaise Hellmann’s or Best Foods recommended
- ⅓ cup apple cider vinegar
- 2 tbsp granulated sugar
- 2 tsp salt
Instructions
- Boil: In a large pot, bring water to a boil and add 2 tsp salt. Add potatoes first. After 2–3 minutes, add macaroni and cook for 6–8 minutes until both are tender. Drain and set aside.
- Mix Dressing: In a separate bowl, whisk together mayo, vinegar, sugar, and salt until smooth.
- Combine: In a large bowl, combine warm potatoes, macaroni, shredded carrots, and onion. Pour dressing over and gently fold until fully coated.
- Chill: Refrigerate at least 5 hours (preferably overnight) before serving.
- Serve: Stir gently before serving. Optionally refresh with a splash of milk or extra mayo if needed.
Notes
| Nutrient | Amount |
|---|---|
| Calories | 380 kcal |
| Total Fat | 22g |
| Saturated Fat | 3.5g |
| Cholesterol | 15mg |
| Sodium | 410mg |
| Carbohydrates | 39g |
| Sugar | 5g |
| Protein | 4g |
| Fiber | 3g |
| Potassium | 550mg |
Ingredients That Make It Authentic
Key Ingredients for Hawaiian Potato Mac Salad
To make the most authentic Hawaiian potato mac salad, you’ve got to start with the basics—but not just any basics. The potatoes? Go for gold potatoes or red ones. Their creamy texture and mild flavor hold up well when chilled. And yes, we’re combining them with macaroni. This isn’t your typical one-carb salad; the combo gives it that signature Hawaiian plate lunch feel.
Next up: carrots and sweet onions. These aren’t just for color—they add texture and just the right touch of sweetness. And trust me, grating the onion finely is a game-changer. No chunks—just flavor that blends into the dressing.
Why the Type of Mayonnaise Matters
In Hawaii, mayonnaise isn’t just a binder—it’s the soul of the salad. That’s why people swear by Best Foods or Hellmann’s (same brand, different names depending on your coast). Its thick, rich, and slightly tangy profile gives this salad its unforgettable creaminess.
Add a splash of apple cider vinegar and a spoonful of granulated sugar to balance the dressing. This combo gives the dish a slightly tangy kick with just enough sweetness to cut through the starch. Salt? Yes, but go easy—you want to enhance the flavors, not overpower them.
When blended together and poured over warm pasta and potatoes, this dressing soaks in deeply. And after a few hours in the fridge? Magic.
Don’t miss our Smoked Potato Salad for another depth-packed flavor profile using simple ingredients.
Step-by-Step Recipe Instructions
How to Prep and Boil the Potatoes and Macaroni
Making Hawaiian potato mac salad isn’t complicated—but timing and texture matter a lot. Start by peeling and dicing your gold potatoes into medium-sized chunks. You don’t want them too small or they’ll turn mushy. Bring a large pot of water to a boil, adding about 2 teaspoons of salt to season everything right from the start.
Here’s the secret: toss your potatoes in first, then wait about 2–3 minutes before adding the macaroni. Why? Because potatoes take just a bit longer to soften, and you want them both done around the same time.
Let them cook until tender—around 6–8 minutes for the pasta. Once everything is soft (but not falling apart), drain and set aside. Don’t rinse them. The starch helps soak up that amazing dressing later. This step sets the base for your ultimate Hawaiian potato mac salad.
Blending and Chilling the Dressing the Right Way
While your potatoes and macaroni cool slightly, whisk up the dressing. In a mixing bowl, combine:
| Ingredient | Amount |
|---|---|
| Mayonnaise (Hellmann’s or Best Foods) | 1 ½ cups |
| Apple cider vinegar | 1/3 cup |
| Granulated sugar | 2 tablespoons |
| Salt | 2 teaspoons |
Whisk until smooth and creamy. The vinegar and sugar bring the tangy-sweet combo that defines a proper Hawaiian potato mac salad.
Now here’s where it all comes together: In a large bowl, toss your warm macaroni and potatoes with shredded carrots and sweet onion. Pour that velvety dressing over the top and gently fold everything together. You want each bite to have a bit of everything.
Refrigerate it for at least 5 hours, or even better—overnight. The longer it chills, the more flavor it soaks up. And when you take that first bite the next day, you’ll understand what makes Hawaiian potato mac salad such a standout side.
Discover great ideas like our Ina Garten French Potato Salad if you’re curious how other cultures dress up this humble root veg.
Tips for Making It Taste Like Hawaiian Bros
Texture Secrets: Shredded Onion, Soft Macaroni
If you’ve ever had a spoonful of Hawaiian Bros-style potato mac salad, you know there’s something special about the texture. It’s creamy without being mushy, with just the right touch of bite. Here’s how to hit that sweet spot.
First, don’t rinse the pasta after boiling. Letting the macaroni cool in its own starch helps it hold the creamy dressing better. And forget al dente—you want the macaroni a little softer than usual. Overcooked? Maybe. Authentic? Definitely.
Next: finely shredded sweet onions. We’re not just chopping here—use a grater or zester. It blends into the base and adds that mellow kick without overwhelming the salad. When people ask what makes Hawaiian potato mac salad taste different, it’s this silky texture and mellow flavor balance that does it.
And those carrots? They’re not just for color. Grate them fine too so they melt right in. The salad should feel like a blend, not a bowl of individual ingredients.
Chill Time and Serving Tricks for Maximum Flavor
A Hawaiian potato mac salad doesn’t shine until it’s been properly chilled. At least five hours is the baseline, but if you can wait overnight, even better. The mayo, vinegar, and sugar dressing soaks into every macaroni tube and potato chunk, creating a dish that’s rich, tangy, and super satisfying.
Want to take it up a notch? After chilling, give it a quick stir, then add a little more mayo to refresh the creaminess. Some island cooks even add a splash of cold milk to loosen it up before serving—just a tablespoon or two does the trick.
Serve it cold, with BBQ chicken, teriyaki beef, or grilled fish. It’s the ultimate Hawaiian comfort pairing.
Check out our Pineapple Cucumber Salad for another tropical side that’s light, vibrant, and perfect with grilled meats.
Hawaiian Potato Mac Salad Variations
With Tuna, Spam, or Boiled Egg Add-Ins
While the classic Hawaiian potato mac salad is unforgettable on its own, locals and home cooks alike love adding a personal twist. One favorite? Canned tuna. It gives a rich, savory depth that turns this side dish into a full-blown meal. Another traditional addition? Diced Spam. Yep—Hawaiians love it, and the salty-savory cubes add bite and boldness.
For extra creaminess and protein, try mixing in chopped hard-boiled eggs. It’s subtle but adds another layer of comfort to every spoonful. These additions are especially popular for lunchboxes and picnics. And because this salad holds up well when cold, it travels like a champ.
No matter what you add, the creamy base still shines—making it unmistakably a Hawaiian potato mac salad with a unique twist.
Making It Spicy, Vegan, or Gluten-Free
Want to give your Hawaiian potato mac salad a bold edge? Add a little sriracha or crushed red pepper into the dressing for a spicy kick. A teaspoon is enough to wake up the flavors without overpowering the traditional taste.
Craving a vegan version? Swap out the mayo for a vegan alternative like Just Mayo or Vegenaise. Use plant-based milk for thinning if needed. The texture and flavor hold up surprisingly well—even island purists have been impressed.
Need gluten-free? Simple fix—use gluten-free elbow macaroni and double-check the vinegar you’re using. Everything else stays the same. You’ll still get that creamy, comforting taste—just without the gluten.
Learn more about how we reinvent classics like the Hellmann’s Potato Salad Recipe with health-friendly tweaks that don’t skimp on flavor.
Nutrition & Health Breakdown
Is Hawaiian Potato Mac Salad Healthy?
Let’s be real—Hawaiian potato mac salad isn’t exactly low-cal. It’s rich, creamy, and carb-loaded. But does that mean it’s unhealthy? Not necessarily. Like any comfort food, it’s all about balance and portion.
A single serving (about ¾ cup) can pack in 300–400 calories, depending on how much mayo you use and if you add extras like Spam or eggs. It’s also high in carbs and fats—which is why it’s so satisfying. But when eaten with lean protein (like grilled chicken or fish), it fits beautifully into a well-rounded meal.
Want to get more technical? Wikipedia’s article on mayonnaise explains how mayo can actually be part of a healthy diet if used in moderation—especially when made with quality oils.
Still wondering how this salad compares to other sides? Wikipedia’s page on macaroni salad gives a helpful overview of its nutritional value across regions, showing how ingredients impact calories and fats.
Smart Swaps to Make It Lighter
You can absolutely enjoy Hawaiian potato mac salad while cutting back a little on the heaviness. Try these:
- Use light mayo or a 50/50 split of mayo and Greek yogurt
- Reduce the pasta-to-potato ratio, adding more veggies like celery or bell pepper
- Add lemon juice to freshen the flavor so you can use less salt
- Use whole wheat or chickpea macaroni to increase fiber
These tweaks don’t change the soul of the dish. You still get that creamy texture and sweet-tangy dressing, but your heart (and waistline) will thank you.
Pairing and Serving Suggestions
What to Serve With Hawaiian Potato Mac Salad
If you’ve ever had a traditional Hawaiian plate lunch, you know Hawaiian potato mac salad is a must-have on the side. But it doesn’t have to be exclusive to island meals. The creaminess and slight sweetness pair perfectly with all kinds of savory mains.
Here are some tried-and-true pairings:
- Grilled teriyaki chicken – the sweet glaze pairs perfectly with the tangy salad
- BBQ pulled pork – the smoky flavors melt into the creamy base
- Mahi-mahi or grilled salmon – keeps the meal light but still satisfying
- Loco Moco – a Hawaiian classic: rice, burger patty, egg, and brown gravy next to a big scoop of mac salad
The chilled, creamy texture of the salad balances out hot, spicy, or smoky dishes like a dream.
Want to keep it casual? Serve Hawaiian potato mac salad at your next cookout alongside grilled burgers, hot dogs, or ribs. It fits in seamlessly with backyard flavors while adding that unique island twist.
Island-Inspired BBQ and Plate Lunch Ideas
To bring that Hawaiian plate lunch vibe to your table, go for presentation. Scoop rice into one corner of the plate, add your protein of choice next to it, and nestle a generous helping of Hawaiian potato mac salad on the side. It’s colorful, hearty, and instantly satisfying.
Garnish with a little extra shredded carrot or chopped parsley for a pop of freshness. And if you want to impress guests? Offer a squeeze of fresh lime or a drizzle of sriracha mayo on the side—it adds flair without overpowering the classic taste.
Looking for inspiration? Try our Steakhouse Potato Salad for a more robust twist on your summer sides.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Skipping the Rest Time
One of the biggest mistakes people make with Hawaiian potato mac salad is not giving it time to chill. This isn’t a salad you toss together and serve right away. The flavors need time to meld—especially the mayo, vinegar, and sugar dressing.
If you serve it too soon, it’ll taste flat and unfinished. The potatoes won’t be creamy yet, and the macaroni might still be hot, which can break the mayo. Give it a minimum of 5 hours in the fridge, though overnight is even better. That rest time is when the magic happens.
So next time you’re planning a BBQ or lunch gathering, make the salad the night before. Trust me—it’s worth it.
Overcooking the Macaroni or Potatoes
Yes, this might sound like a contradiction—since we do want the macaroni slightly overcooked for that traditional Hawaiian texture. But there’s a difference between soft and mushy. If you overcook the pasta or potatoes too much, they’ll break down in the dressing, turning your salad into mashed goo.
Keep your eye on the pot:
- Boil macaroni until very tender, but still holds its shape
- Potatoes should be soft enough to pierce with a fork, but not falling apart
And when draining? Be gentle. You want every chunk and piece intact so that the final Hawaiian potato mac salad has that creamy-but-chunky, satisfying consistency.
Don’t miss our Blog Roundup for more fun meal pairings and serving styles inspired by authentic flavors.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Why does Hawaiian mac salad taste different?
Hawaiian mac salad has a uniquely rich and tangy flavor that sets it apart from traditional versions. It uses Best Foods or Hellmann’s mayonnaise, a splash of apple cider vinegar, and a bit of sugar—all of which create that iconic sweet-tangy taste. But the real difference? The overcooked macaroni and warm mixing technique. When everything is stirred together while still warm, the pasta soaks up the creamy dressing in a way that’s deeply satisfying. That’s why Hawaiian potato mac salad has such a nostalgic, crave-worthy flavor.
What is Hawaiian style potato salad?
Hawaiian-style potato salad often blends both boiled potatoes and elbow macaroni—a combination not commonly found in other regions. It’s heavy on mayonnaise, slightly sweet, and super creamy. Carrots and sweet onions are usually shredded into the mix, and the result is a tender, comforting salad that pairs perfectly with grilled or smoked meats. What makes it unique isn’t just the ingredients, but how they’re layered and chilled to soak up flavor over time.
What is the difference between Hawaiian mac salad and mac salad?
The key difference lies in preparation and flavor. Regular mac salad usually uses al dente pasta, simple ingredients like celery or peas, and a lighter touch of mayo. But Hawaiian mac salad (and Hawaiian potato mac salad) goes all in on richness. The pasta is cooked soft, then coated in a mayo-heavy dressing with hints of vinegar and sugar. It also includes potatoes in some variations, creating a thicker, more filling texture. That extra creaminess and balance of tang and sweetness make all the difference.
What’s in Hawaiian Bros mac salad?
Hawaiian Bros mac salad is their take on the classic Hawaiian potato mac salad. It’s ultra-creamy, super smooth, and made with simple ingredients: elbow macaroni, mayo, apple cider vinegar, a pinch of sugar, shredded carrots, and onions. They also chill it thoroughly, giving it that dense, silky texture fans love. While the exact recipe is under wraps, it follows the traditional island approach—no mustard, no pickles, just pure creamy goodness.
Bring a Taste of Aloha to Your Table
Making Hawaiian potato mac salad isn’t just about tossing together pasta, potatoes, and mayo. It’s about creating a dish that carries comfort, culture, and flavor in every spoonful. From the warm memories of grandma’s kitchen to the joy of a backyard BBQ, this salad has a way of bringing people together.
Whether you’re enjoying it with smoky ribs, grilled fish, or teriyaki chicken, its creamy, tangy personality elevates every plate. And with the tips, tricks, and variations we’ve covered, you can make your own version just as comforting—and even more personal.
So don’t just treat it like a side dish. Give it time to rest, serve it chilled, and enjoy every creamy bite like the island locals do—with heart and simplicity.
FOLLOW ME IN PINTEREST FOR MORE RECIPES
